Sunday, July 6, 2008

All-Stars are mostly deserving


Ca - Joe Mauer, MIN
1B - Kevin Youkilis, BOS
2B - Dustin Pedroia, BOS
SS - Derek Jeter, NYY
3B - Alex Rodriguez, 3B
OF - Josh Hamilton, TEX
OF - Manny Ramirez, BOS
OF - Ichiro Suzuki, SEA

Dioner Navarro (C-TBR), Jason Varitek (C-BOS), Joe Crede (3B-CHW), Carlos Guillen (IF-DET), Ian Kinsler (2B-TEX), Justin Morneau (1B-MIN), Michael Young (SS-TEX), J.D. Drew (OF-BOS), Carlos Quentin (OF-CHW), Grady Sizemore (OF-CLE)

Notable absences - Milton Bradley (OF-TEX), 177 OPS+, .434 OBP; Jason Giambi (1B-NYY), 150 OPS+, .395 OBP; Jermaine Dye (OF-CHW), 140 OPS+, .362 OBP

Shitty picks - Jason Varitek 73 OPS+, .301 OBP; Derek Jeter 97 OPS+, .345 OBP; Ichiro Suzuki 103 OPS+, .362 OBP; Michael Young 105 OPS+, .342 OBP

Questionable picks - Dustin Pedroia 114 OPS+, .357 OBP; Joe Crede 113 OPS+, .308 OBP


Ca - Goevany Soto, CHI
1B - Lance Berkamn, HOU
2B - Chase Utley, PHI
SS - Hanley Ramirez, FLA
3B - Chipper Jones, ATL
OF - Ryan Braun, MIL
OF - Kosuke Fukudome, CHI
OF - Alfonso Soriano, CHI

Russell Martin (Ca-LAD), Brian McCann (Ca-ATL), Adrian Gonzalez (1B-SDP), Cristian Guzman (SS-WSH), Albert Pujols (1B-STL), Aramis Ramirez (3B-CHC), Miguel Tejada (SS-HOU), Dan Uggla (2B-FLA), Matt Holliday (OF-COL), Ryan Ludwick (OF-STL), Nate McLouth (OF-PIT)

Notable Absences - Pat Burrell (OF-PHI), 155 OPS+, .410 OBP; Xavier Nady (OF-PIT), 145 OPS+, .382 OBP

Shitty Picks - Cristian Guzman (104 OPS+, .342 OBP), Miguel Tejada (99 OPS+, .319 OBP)

Questionable Pick - Kosuke Fukudom (112 OPS+, .391 OBP)

Seems like the National League has a better idea on what they're doing. If the All-Star game is supposed to count, why is the AL bringing Jason Varitek? Unless you're a Red Sox fan or an idiot, he is about as deserving to be on an All-Star team as Kevin Cash (69 OPS+, .308 OBP), the Sox backup catcher. The Challenger explosion was less of a tragedy.

Ichiro instead of Milton Bradley? Bradley has 14 more homers, 33 more RBI, and is .072 higher in OBP. Picking Ichiro is like picking George W. Bush to run a country.

Update: Bradley is in due to Ortiz being selected despite being on the disabled list for like two months. So...good for Bradley.


Neil said...

This is why fans shouldn't be allowed to vote?

ChrisV82 said...

If it counts, fans probably shouldn't vote, but then again, the players voted in Varitek, so maybe MLB should just not have the All-Star game matter towards home field advantage.